Which one to choose????

I have 2 finals choices for my countertops. Hubby did not want to go with quartz so we opted for granite instead. I like them both but not sure which one to go with. Here's what they look like.

You can see depending on the light how they either get darker or lighter. My cabinets are dark cherry and my floor is of a warm light mocha color. If anyone has any opinions, I am open to hearing them. (although K has told me she was ok with my 2 choices. LOL)

A bientot!